You added trust badges. You sped the site up. You swapped the photos for nicer ones. Then you waited. Nothing.
If that’s you, you’re in good company:
“What do you mean by trust signals? I added reviews and some badges but I can work out more.”
— Reddit, r/ecommerce
Here’s my view, up front. Trust badges, page speed and photos aren’t wrong. They’re just the wrong order. They polish a message. They can’t fix a missing one.
Why everyone tries these three first
Because it’s what the internet tells you to do. Search “why isn’t my website converting” and you’ll get some version of this:
“First thing I’d do is add reviews, trust badges, and some kind of urgency or social proof to your product pages.”
— Reddit, r/shopify
They’re also easy. You can add a badge in five minutes, run a speed plugin in an afternoon and buy new photos by Friday. It feels like progress.
And they’re the things you can see. The real problem is usually something you can’t see, because you wrote it: the message at the top of the page.
Trust badges: what they actually do
Trust badges (the Norton, McAfee, “secure checkout” and card-logo icons) do have real research behind them, but it’s narrower than people think.
The Baymard Institute, which runs large-scale checkout usability research, found that people judge security by how a page looks, not how secure it actually is. Seals and visual cues help most around the card payment fields at checkout (Baymard Institute). In a 2013 survey of US shoppers, Norton and McAfee seals were the most trusted, and almost half of people (49%) had no preference at all (Baymard Institute).
So trust badges matter most at one point: when someone is about to type their card number into an online shop.
If you’re a plumber, a solicitor or an estate agent, nobody’s typing a card number into your homepage. A row of badges in your footer won’t do much. What builds trust for a service business is different:
- Real reviews, sitting next to your enquiry form, not on a separate page
- Your real name and face
- A clear answer to “what happens after I get in touch?”
My trust and conversion check looks for exactly these.
Faster loading: it matters, but it can’t rescue a confusing page
Speed is real. A study commissioned by Google and carried out by Deloitte looked at 37 brands and over 30 million sessions. On lead generation sites, a 0.1 second improvement in mobile speed raised the share of people going from the first form step to submitting the form by 21.6% (web.dev).
So yes, make your site fast. But speed gets people onto the page. It doesn’t give them a reason to stay. A fast page that doesn’t say what you do just loses people more quickly.
“Slow load time combined with no clear headline.”
— Reddit, r/smallbusiness
That person left for both reasons, and you’ll notice only one of them is about speed.
A warning about speed statistics. You’ll see claims like “every one-second delay costs you 7% of conversions” or “you lose 70% of visitors after five seconds” all over the internet. Be careful. The 7% figure gets quoted two different ways: Akamai’s 2017 retail report said a 100 millisecond delay, while other versions say a whole second and trace back to a much older report I couldn’t find the original of. I couldn’t trace the “70% after five seconds” claim to any source at all. If you can’t find where a number came from, don’t build your plans on it.
To check your own speed, use Google’s free PageSpeed Insights. Google’s own guide is that the main content should load within 2.5 seconds. My mobile experience check measures this on your real pages.
New photos: people skip decoration
Nielsen Norman Group, a long-running usability research firm, used eye-tracking to see what people actually look at on web pages. They found people ignore decorative “feel-good” stock photos, but look closely at photos of real people, and at product photos that help them compare or decide (Nielsen Norman Group).
So new photos only help if they show something real: your work, your team, you.
“your about us is full of stock photos, even the photo of you, isn’t you (easily found)”
— Reddit, r/ecommerce
And even good photos can’t do the job alone:
“I’m getting some visitors now after improving my product photos but still not getting conversions.”
— Reddit, r/smallbusiness
What was actually wrong (usually)
In my experience, it’s the message. The top of the page doesn’t say, in plain words, who it’s for, what you do and why someone should pick you.
“if someone has to stop and figure out what you actually do, you’ve probably already lost them”
— Reddit, r/GrowthHacking
Most business websites talk about the business: how long they’ve been going, how proud they are, what they provide. The visitor doesn’t care yet. They care about their problem. Until the page talks about that, badges, speed and photos are decorating a shop window that doesn’t say what the shop sells.
I go into how I check this in what is conversion rate optimisation: the three questions a stranger asks in their first few seconds.
The order I’d fix things in
- The message. The top of the page says what you do, who it’s for and what they get, in their words.
- Proof where the doubt is. Real reviews next to the form and the button, not on a page of their own.
- One clear next step. One obvious thing to do, and it’s easy on a phone.
- Speed and mobile. Now make it quick, so nobody leaves before they read step 1.
- Photos and badges. Real photos of real work. Badges only where card details are entered.
That order matters, because each step depends on the one before it. A fast page with great photos still loses people if step 1 is wrong.
Not sure which one is your problem?
That’s what my free website audit is for. It scores your site out of 100 across design, copy, SEO, trust and mobile, so you can see which one is actually holding you back, with a screenshot and a fix for every finding. It takes about ten minutes, and there’s no card and no call.
Frequently asked questions
Do trust badges increase conversions?
They can help at checkout, where people enter card details. That’s where most of the research points. For service businesses without an online checkout, real reviews next to your enquiry form will do far more. Be wary of anyone promising a set percentage increase from badges.
How fast should my website load?
Google’s own guide is that the main content of a page should load within 2.5 seconds. You can test your site for free with Google’s PageSpeed Insights.
Should I use stock photos on my website?
Use real photos wherever you can: your work, your team, you. Research shows people tend to ignore generic stock photos and look closely at real ones.
Why is my website getting visitors but no enquiries?
Usually because the page doesn’t quickly tell a stranger what you do, who it’s for and why they should choose you. Fix the message first, then the proof, then the path to contact you.
—